Our Plan

1 Project Characteristics

1.1 Relevance for the Internet

  • Providing better access to user groups who have not had barrier-free access to the WWW and the acoustic web, A.K.A. podcasts.
  • Panodio uses data of the currently existing platform Panoptikum https://panoptikum.io, which is developed, maintained and hosted in Austria by the project team.
  • Further exposure of local active podcasters to international audiences.

1.2 How is the Product Made Available to the Public?

  • Download an Android application with an voice interface for tablets and smartphones from the website of the project as well as free app stores like F-Droid and the Google Play Store.
  • Audio interface removes barriers for physically challenged and visually impaired internet users.
  • Stores a minimal amount of data to provide access.
  • Pseudonymity — users are encouraged to make wrong statements on their names, or create several accounts to preserve their anonymity.
  • No connection or correlation to accounts on the major commercial platforms.

1.3 Outreach

  • Planned talks at conferences: A-Tag’18, Subscribe(s), 35C3, Re:Publica, Podcasting Meetup, Privacy Week, other meetups in the meetup scene in Vienna: Project Night, Webclerks, Android Heads Meetup Vienna, etc.
  • Distribution via the podcasting community, that is, the podcasters who are Panoptikum.io users
  • Making use of the existing platform and community of Panoptikum.io.
  • Project homepage.
  • Österreichischer Blindenverband, Hilfsgemeinschaft der Blinden und Sehschwachen Ö.s, libraries for the blind in Austria and Germany.

2 Project Description

2.1 Project Goals

  • Android application with voice interface only.
  • Access to more than 1.800.000 podcast episodes from the database via the Panoptikum API.
  • No UI interaction aside from voice for using the application is necessary.
  • Accessibility-friendly project website to download the application, including descriptions in text and audio format.
  • Availability in at least three app stores.
  • Project documentation in German and English.

2.2 State of the Art Technology & Method

  • Speech-to-text — users have to be able to speak and talk are the only prerequisites.
  • Natural Language Processing (NLP) used to recognize the intent.
  • Search for desired content within Panoptikum.io and verbal presentation of the search results.
  • Playback or appending to a playlist.

2.3 Solutions and Suggestions

  • Android speech-to-text API.
  • Speech recognition — Natural Language Processing (NLP).
  • Android application (wide adoption of devices, high availability for reasonably priced devices).
  • Requests to the Panoptikum.io’s database via web requests (API).
  • Smartphones (small, headphone usage, small/loud speakers, usage off the power grid).
  • Tablets (bigger, better sounding load speakers, usage off the power grid)

2.4 Risks

  • Quality of speech to text recognition in German.
  • Quality of the data model.
  • User (voice) interface needs to be intuitive.
  • Availability of users with diverse demands for acceptance testing.
  • Support of older Android phones, to be able to use as many smartphones as possible at hand.

2.5 Rough Time Estimates

  • 2 months: Pre-project marketing: Subscribe, Meetups, Re:Publica.
  • 1 month: Setup of team und and development stack.
  • 1 month: Test and selection of components used.
  • 3 months: Development of minimal application.
  • 2 months: Tests.
  • 2 months: Further development of application.
  • 2 months: Deployment.
  • 2 months: Marketing and launch.
  • 12 months (in parallel): congresses and meetups.

2.6 Time Estimates in Further Detail

  • Pre-project marketing: 60 hours
  • Setup: 100 hours
  • Testing and selection of components: 120 hours
  • Development of minimal application (MVP): 300 hours
  • Tests with users with diverse demands as well as definiton of differing requirements: 120 hours
  • Expansion of application and further development: 300 hours
  • Deployment and rollout tests: 150 hours
  • Marketing and launch: 200 hours
  • Congresses and meetups, marketing & media coverage: 120 hours
  • Documentation: 100 hours
  • Project lead: 100 hours

2.7 Key Performance Indicatiors

Description Minimal success Tremendous success
Languages available 1 3
Talks given at conferences and meetups 5 10
Podcast episodes available 1 800 000 2 500 000
Downloads (and installs) in 2018 100 1000
Availability in app stores 3 5

2.8 Statement of Qualification of Project Contributors

In the order of joining the project:

  • Stefan / projekt lead und development: https://stefan-haslinger.at/cv
    • Java development since 1997 at UT Vienna as scientific collaborator
    • Developer Panoptikum: https://panoptikum.io/ - https://github.com/PanoptikumIO
    • 7 years web application development: https://github.com/haslinger
    • 7 years SAP-development
    • University degree in physics, mathematics and computer science education
  • Sonja / marketing & community: https://www.waldgruber.at
    • Product management at Austria’s largest ISPs (EuNet, A1)
    • UX testing internship for university degree in psychology (cognition psychology) as well as a consultant in the insurance business
    • Organiser Chaos macht Schule Austria
    • Speaker Privacy Week Austria, Internet für alle
    • University degrees in business and technology as well as psychology
  • Ramon / developer: http://ramonhuidobro.com/
    • University education: software engineering
    • Bachelor theses didactics of computer science
    • Organiser in the Viennese meetup scene for several years
    • Five years of Android- and web develoment
  • Heinz / Acceptance tests
    • Blind
    • Former head of the Austrian acoustic library for the war-blind
    • Law Doctorate
  • Indigo / consulting
    • University degree in computer science, specialized in artificial intelligence

2.9 Relevant Literature

  • Android speech to text API (Recognizer Intent)
  • CMUSphinx Tutorial: https://cmusphinx.github.io/wiki/tutorial/
  • WIT.ai API
  • Java Android API
  • Books:
    • Android Programming: The Big Nerd Ranch Guide
    • Android 7
    • Programming Phoenix
    • Programming Elixir

3 Pestel Analysis and Applications

3.1 Current Activities in the Project Area

Development and operations of Panoptikum.io:

  • podcast directory, search engine and social network: https://panoptikum.io/
  • meta informationen about the project: https://blog.panoptikum.io/
  • proof for continous development with more than 50 blog posts accompaning development: https://blog.panoptikum.io/blog/

3.2 Unique Selling Point (USP) Compared with Existing Solutions from Other Vendors

  • Initial touch anywhere on the screen starts voice interface (privacy concerns against continous monitoring)
  • No vision necessary
  • No proprietary hardware necessary, compatibility with a huge amount of Android driven smart phones and tablets
  • All software written (including the Panoptikum.io directory) is open source and free software

3.3 Target groups

We pick here only the biggest group of visually impaired, however the application is open for all people that are able to hear and speak to use:

  • Visually impaired in Austria ~ 318.000
  • Visually impaired in Germany ~ 1.800.000
  • Visually impaired world wide ~ 285.000.000

3.4 Advantages for Users

  • After the initial installation, no visual user interface has to be used, voice input suffices
  • There is no need to learn a new skill for non-technical people. Speech is a well-known medium.
  • No propriatary hardware is necessary (in contrast to, for example, for an Amazon Alexa Skill)
  • No accounts at the major platforms that resell or reuse data commercially are necessary (Facebook, Google, Amazon, etc.)

3.5 Sustainability

  • Uoftware will be AGPL 3 licensed, i.e. freely extendable, adaptable and updateable.
  • AGPL garantees, that there will be no restrictions on later licensing conditions or prerequisits.
  • No restrictions by patents.
  • Financing of platform operations and updates via
    • Donations
    • Pro accounts for podcasters using the Panoptikum backend
  • Cooperation with content distributors and broadcasting corporations.

Extensions after 2018 extending the area of podcasts:

  • Internet radio streams (real time information, there are several thousand streams available)
  • Audio content, that is not distributed via feeds, such as spoken Wikipedia
  • Content from media centers, e.g. provided for the public by public broadcasting corporations
  • Content from web pages, that already offer reading aloud services, that are only accessible Via web browsers up to now.
  • Integration of content, that is currently distributed via Daisy(~MP3)-CDs by libraries for Visually impaired.
  • Audio communication between users (voice chat).

Combined: Access to all parts of the acoustic web.

3.6 Intellectual Property

All artifacts will be licensed under the AGPL3 license:

  • Application source code on Github:https://github.com/PanoptikumIO/panodio: AGPL3
  • Application compiled via the web site and in several app stores for download: AGPL3

Dual licensed also via GPL FDL & CC4.0:

  • Documentation for developers in the Github wiki: https://github.com/PanoptikumIO/panodio/wiki:
  • Documentation for users on the web site (https://panodio.panoptikum.io)
  • Information for cooperating partners on the project web site

3.7 Opportunites for Cooperation with Interesting Scientific or Economic Aspects?

  • Libraries (for visually impaired).
  • Broadcasting corporations.
  • Universities and universities of applied sciences (speech recognition, UX design).
  • Municipalities that already provide acoustic services, e.g. City of Vienna.
  • Producers of aids to the blind (for example, in Austria: Baum Retec GmbH).
  • Podcast platforms: Google (Podcast Store, currently only in the US), Apple, Amazon, etc.

3.8 Positive Aspects for Regional Policy

Municipalities and other institutions with reading services (City of Vienna, for example) publish their audio content typically only in web pages browseable by web browsers. This content can be available via speech navigation with Panodio.

3.9 Are there any Noteworthy Social, Environmental or Public Spirited Aspects?

  • Higher education (1000+ scientific podcasts) leads to better employability
  • A larger focus is set on the acoustic web, which is currently largely neglected (hardly anybody knows about spoken Wikipedia)
  • Lots of persons currently not being able to participate actively in the world wide web would no longer be excluded.

3.10 Which Particular Role Can this Project Take for “Closing the gender gap”?

  • Voice interface leads to a low entrance barrier.
  • Better accessibility for elderly, visually impaired people, or those not yet participating in the internet.
  • Easy entrance to the world of podcasts requiring little to no previous technical knowledge.
  • No training necessary, the device introduces itself and its usage to the users

3.11 Which Particular Relevance has “Privacy by Design”?

  • Development guided by the principle of data sparsity.
  • User data are only stored, if necessary, only on the device itself, and not in the web backend.
  • There is no enforcement of real names in the backend.

4 Project Costs

4.1 Labor Costs in Hours

Description Amount (hours)
Documentation - Stefan, Ramon and Sonja 100
Tests - Heinz, Stefan and Ramon 40
Marketing and community - Sonja 200
Development - Stefan und Ramon 950
Project lead - Stefan 100
Sum 1390

4.2 Other Costs in EUR

Description Amount (EUR)
Hosting, domain, mail service 500
Print and production of marketing material (sticker, folder, shirts) 1000
Travel expenses + congress tickets 3000
Literature 300
Sum 4800